REAL ESTATE
For agentsBuySellInternationalCryptoJournal
ENES
ENES
For agentsBuySellInternationalCryptoJournal414.712.6275
REAL ESTATE
For agentsBuySellInternationalCryptoJournal
ENES
ENES
For agentsBuySellInternationalCryptoJournal414.712.6275
REAL ESTATE
For agentsBuySellInternationalCryptoJournal
ENES
ENES
For agentsBuySellInternationalCryptoJournal414.712.6275
← Back to search

For sale· 49 days on market

1849 1st St, Milwaukee, WI 53212

MLS# 1977211·Courtesy of Premier Point Realty LLC

$630,000

≈ Estimated $4,127/mo estimated

·4 bd·, 3 ba·, 3,292 sq ft·, 0.24 ac lot

1 / 52of 52 photos
4
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
3,292
Sq ft
0.24 ac
Lot size
1875
Year built
$191
Per sq ft
  • Residential
  • Built 1875

About this home

They simply do not build houses like this anymore. Dating to 1875, this Cream City brick Victorian is a true piece of Brewer's Hill history, filled with the craftsmanship, scale and character that make Milwaukee's oldest homes so special. Original hardwood floors, substantial millwork, soaring ceilings and oversized windows set the tone from the moment you walk in. The home has been thoughtfully improved while allowing its historic details to remain the star. Four bedrooms include a remarkable two-story primary suite, while the double lot offers a fenced yard, brick patio, private driveway and oversized 22x32 garage. With central air and modern conveniences already in place, this is a chance to own something genuinely distinctive in one of Milwaukee's most iconic historic neighborhoods.

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
3 full
Living area
3,292 sqft

Property

Type
Residential
Year built
1875
Lot size
0.24 acres

Financial

Annual taxes
$14,200.57
Price / sqft
$191

Estimate your monthly payment

$126,000
%
%
yrs

$4,127/ month estimated

  • Principal & interest$3,286
  • Property tax$578
  • Insurance$263

Illustrative estimate — not a lending offer.

Investor tools

See flip, rental and BRRR numbers for this home.

Location

Milwaukee, WI

Ask me about 1849 1st St

Call, text, or send a message. I'll answer myself, same day, in English or Spanish.

Call or text 414.712.6275Ask a question

Pedro Rivera

My agent · 414.712.6275

Choose a day

        

Choose a time of day

Free, no obligation · I confirm within the hour during business hours.

CallText

Listing data courtesy of Premier Point Realty LLC. My request routes to Pedro Rivera in DashBrew CRM.

Metro MLS

reThought Real Estate does not guarantee listing accuracy.

Property information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Pedro Rivera
Pedro RiveraAs seen on · Media coverage
TMJ4Telemundo WisconsinCBS 58 Wisconsin
REAL ESTATE
CALL OR TEXT · HABLAMOS ESPAÑOL
414.712.6275
Pedro J Rivera, Broker & Founder
reThought Real Estate · Kissimmee, FL & Milwaukee, WI
Email
BUY
Orlando homesKissimmee homesMilwaukee homesBuying process
SELL
My home's valueListing processSeller's guide
AREAS
OrlandoKissimmeeSt. CloudMilwaukeeWauwatosaAll areas →
MORE
For agentsInternational projectsCryptoCalculatorsJournalWho is Pedro?
© 2026 PEDRO J RIVERA · BROKER, reTHOUGHT REAL ESTATE · LIC FL & WI
LIC FL & WIPRIVACYTERMSEQUAL HOUSING
Call Direct: 414.712.6275WhatsApp

$630,000

4 bed, 3 bath, 3,292 sqft

Request showing

Around Brewer's Hill

Map of the Brewer's Hill outline with this home and nearby schools marked.Brewer's Hill

Schools near this home

3 nearby
  1. A
    Milwaukee College Preparatory School -- Lloyd StreetGrades Pre-K to 8 · Charter
    Rating: 1 of 50.9 mi
  2. B
    Milwaukee College Preparatory School: Lola Rowe North CampusGrades Pre-K to 8 · Charter
    Rating: 1 of 51.0 mi
  3. C
    Alliance School of MilwaukeeGrades 9 to 12 · Charter
    Rating: 0 of 50.6 mi

Attendance zones aren't guaranteed. Verify with the school district.

Homes for sale in Brewer's Hill

As of Nov 7
Homes for sale
17
Middle ask
$374,900
New this week
0
Average days listed
38

These numbers use homes for sale only.

Neighborhood boundaries and school data: LiveBy

Similar homes nearby

3958 1st Pl

$265,000

2 bd · 2 ba · 826 sqft

3958 1st Pl

Courtesy of RE/MAX Preferred-Delafield

8088 Potomac Ave

$244,900

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,207 sqft

8088 Potomac Ave

Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty

3775 87th St

$399,900

6 bd · 0 ba

3775 87th St

Courtesy of Green Earth Realty